Firefighters Praise DaVinci Composite Roofing
“The composite roof is the only thing that saved this house.” That’s what firefighters told the Sandnes family when a third-floor fire erupted in their historic home.
“The firefighters were very clear,” says homeowner Gina Sandnes. “They told us that with any other roofing material the fire would have spread quickly, and the house would have burned to the ground. Instead, because we had DaVinci composite roofing, the St. Paul, Minnesota, fire department was able to save a valuable piece of our city’s history.”
Fire-Resistant Roofing
The horrible fire started in the early afternoon on March 1, 2023. This was less than five months after the Sandnes family purchased the eclectic English country manor.
Several years earlier the previous homeowner had fought to gain approval from the historic commission to allow DaVinci roofing on the home. Located on the city’s famous Summit Avenue, the longest preserved stretch of Victorian homes in the U.S., the house was constructed in 1883. That meant changes needed to conform to precise guidelines of the commission.

The former owner believed the DaVinci Multi-Width Slate he wished to put on the home not only had the aesthetic look of real slate, but an abundance of “bonus features.” The composite tiles are lighter in weight, making them easier on the “old bones” infrastructure of the home. In addition, the composite slate resists insects and termites. And, as a key point, it’s both Class A Fire and Class 4 impact resistant.
“We’re so fortunate that the previous owner had the foresight to research composite roofing,” says Sandnes. “Then he fought for it. That’s a decision that actually saved this landmark home.”
Sold on DaVinci
When the fire burned through the roof, it refused to spread, because of the composite tiles. As a result, it remained isolated to a hole just several feet wide on the roof. However, because of the fire’s damage inside the third floor of the home, a new roof still needed to be replaced. What did the Sandnes family choose?
“There was no question we would go with anything except a DaVinci roof,” says Sandnes. “There’s nothing going on top of any of our homes in the future other than DaVinci.”
Top-to-Bottom Roofing Restoration
The team at Allstar Construction was brought in to handle the reconstruction of the third floor, the reroofing and the full scope of the restoration work. This includes everything from rebuilding the interior roof’s structural system to painting, flooring, window installation and masonry.
“There was inconsistent construction on the home previously and unexpected structural problems that challenged the reconstruction process,” according to Nate Limerick with Allstar Construction out of Maple Plain, Minnesota. “These issues required additional time and adjustments to address properly.”
The Allstar team worked on the roofing restoration project for four months. When it came to the roof, the most challenging part was assuring that the new structural system was properly aligned and secure before the DaVinci product could be installed.
“Even though the DaVinci Multi-Width Slate tiles held the fire back and burned in just some places, the whole roof had to be replaced,” says Limerick. “The fire caused structural damage that affected the integrity of the complete roofing system. It’s possible the heat from the fire may have compromised the strength of the roofing product so that it no longer lived up to its high standards. That’s why the entire roof had to be replaced.”
Limerick relates that the roof installation was a straightforward job, taking about a month to complete. The DaVinci Masterpiece Contractor installs upwards of 20 DaVinci roofs each year, but this project brought an interesting twist — a top-to-bottom porte-cochere roof application.
“There’s a unique asymmetrical extension of the uppermost gable forming the main roof, creating a dramatic roof covering for the porte-cochere,” says Limerick. “And, it’s very impressive at about three stories tall!”
Exceptional Contractor Support
Now completely restored, the 140+ year old home again stands out amongst the famous mansions on Summit Avenue. The Slate Gray composite roof continues to draw attention to the “cat-slide” porte-cochere while the homeowners give thanks that modern-day technology helped save the historic home.
“We can’t say enough good things about the DaVinci product,” says Sandnes. “I truly believe the DaVinci roof saved our house.
“In addition, I’m super happy with Allstar Construction. They’re responsive, kind and trustworthy. All their workers are wonderful and they were just great to work with on this project.
“I would absolutely recommend Allstar. Especially for roofing projects. But more than that. They were also my general contractors on the whole job. I was extremely pleased and would highly recommend them for any project.”
Award-Winning Project
For the exceptional work done in restoring this historic home, Allstar Construction has been named as a winner of a 2024 DaVinci Masterpiece Contractor of the Year Award.
Only five residential projects in the country are receiving the award in 2024. The Allstar Construction team earned the honor based on the excellence they displayed on the installation work, outstanding visual impact and ability of the roofing work to transform the look of this project.
Protect Your Home with DaVinci
Reach out to our Project Specialist team for expert advice and personalized recommendations.